Short answer
Usually the same people as for any online card sale: the shopper can dispute the charge, the card issuer decides, and the merchant loses the money if it can't show the sale was valid. Visa's rules now say a cardholder is responsible for what a registered agent does on their behalf, but we found no card network that has published a separate dispute process for agent purchases. Keep clear records of what was ordered, approved and delivered.
Key takeaways
- Normal card dispute rules still apply to agent orders.
- Visa holds cardholders responsible for registered agents' actions.
- Your best protection is a clear record of each agent order.
Who pays when an AI agent buys the wrong thing?
In most cases, the same party who pays when any online card sale goes wrong: the merchant, unless it can show the sale was valid.
Here is how it works today. A shopper who doesn't recognise a charge, or who got the wrong item, contacts their card issuer. The issuer can open a dispute. Your payment provider takes the money back while the dispute runs, and you can submit evidence. The issuer decides.
Stripe puts it plainly: it "facilitates your case, but doesn't have influence over the outcome, which is at the sole discretion of the account owner's bank." Stripe also says it debits "the disputed amount, plus a dispute fee" from your account when a dispute opens.
An AI agent in the middle doesn't change that machinery. What it changes is the argument. The shopper may say "I asked my agent for one, not ten" or "I never told it to buy that". You will want to show what the shopper actually allowed.
Disputes and liability for agent purchases are still being worked out by the card networks. This article covers what is published now. It is general information, not legal advice. Talk to your payment provider or a lawyer about your own situation.
What do Visa's rules say about agent purchases?
Visa has written agent purchases into its public rulebook. Its rules make the cardholder responsible for what a registered agent does for them.
The 24 October 2026 edition of the Visa Core Rules and Visa Product and Service Rules has a section called "Agentic Platform Requirements", with entries marked as last updated in April 2026. The key points:
- It covers a defined kind of purchase. Visa defines an "Agentic Transaction" as an electronic commerce transaction made by an "Agentic Payment Provider" on behalf of a cardholder, based on the cardholder's payment instructions, without direct interaction between the cardholder and the merchant.
- The agent platform must register. An Agentic Payment Provider must "Enroll in and comply with the Visa Intelligent Commerce program and register with Visa".
- The cardholder takes responsibility. Before buying, the provider must "Obtain Cardholder acknowledgement that they are responsible for actions taken by the Agentic Payment Provider". A separate rule says: "A Cardholder is responsible for any actions taken by an Agentic Payment Provider as part of an Agentic Transaction as if the Cardholder initiated the Transaction."
- The agent must stay inside the instructions. The provider must "Use only the Cardholder-defined criteria for purchasing the goods or services".
- The shopper gets a receipt. After the purchase, the provider must give the cardholder an order confirmation for at least 120 days, including your contact details, the total price and your cancellation and refund policies.
Two limits matter. These rules govern Visa's clients and registered agent platforms, not your store directly. And they describe one kind of agent purchase. They don't say how a purchase that falls outside that definition is treated. If an agent simply types a saved card into your checkout, ask your payment provider how it will be classified.
Can shoppers still dispute an agent purchase?
Yes. Visa's rules say a merchant "must not require a Cardholder to waive the right to dispute a Transaction, including an Agentic Transaction, with the Issuer."
So "the shopper's agent bought it" is not a complete defence. What helps is evidence that the purchase matched what the shopper allowed.
In the public Visa rulebook we read, the dispute chapter mentions agent purchases in one place: the rules for card-absent fraud disputes (dispute condition 10.4). For disputes processed from 24 October 2026, evidence that links a disputed purchase to two earlier, undisputed purchases on the same card can include a matching login ID, and Visa says this "also includes login IDs for an Agentic Payment Provider". We found no separate dispute reason for agent purchases.
Visa's developer documentation for its Intelligent Commerce program also links instructions to disputes. For a purchase the shopper approved, it says the purchase instruction is "Required to evidence the specific authorized transaction for disputes." When Visa announced the program in April 2025, it said: "Commerce signals are shared in real-time with Visa, enabling Visa to effect transaction controls and help to manage disputes."
What about Mastercard and American Express?
They are building ways to prove what the shopper intended, but we did not find a published dispute rule for agent purchases from either network at the time of writing.
Mastercard. Mastercard contributed its Verifiable Intent framework, co-developed with Google and designed to work with AP2, to the FIDO Alliance in April 2026. In the FIDO Alliance's announcement, Mastercard's representative said it "creates a shared record of user intent that the entire payments ecosystem can rely on." For how it works, see our Verifiable Intent entry.
American Express. Amex describes its Agent Purchase Protection as a future commitment: "In the future, if a Card Member authorizes a registered AI agent to make a purchase, and that agent sends American Express the customer's authenticated purchase intent, American Express will protect eligible customers from charges related to AI agent error." Its summary terms say this applies only after the cardmember "has initiated a return (where possible) with the merchant", and that it "is in addition to ordinary course dispute resolution processes". Amex says full terms will come later. It protects cardmembers. It is not a merchant guarantee.
For the wider picture of agent payment programs, read how card networks handle AI agents.
Who handles the dispute: you, the agent or the platform?
Usually you. The platforms that send agent orders say so in their own documentation.
- OpenAI. Its merchant guide for agent payments says: "Your business handles the order, fulfillment, customer support, and fraud decisions." See what ChatGPT Wallet means for merchants.
- Stripe. In Stripe's Agentic Commerce Suite, the orders stage is yours: "Fulfill orders, and handle refunds and disputes." When you take a payment with a Shared Payment Token, Stripe says later events such as refunds "behave as if you provided the PaymentMethod directly."
Timing follows normal card rules. Stripe says card networks "typically allow cardholders to initiate disputes within 120 days of the original payment", and that you usually have 7 to 21 days to respond once a chargeback is created.
What evidence helps you win an agent purchase dispute?
A record that shows what the shopper allowed, what the agent ordered, and that you delivered it.
This is where agent payment protocols help. AP2, the Agent Payments Protocol, describes itself as providing "a non-repudiable, cryptographic audit trail for every transaction". Its security notes say a shared hash links a purchase's mandates "allowing them to be joined in the case of a Dispute." In plain terms: a signed agent mandate can show the limits a shopper set.
What to keep for each agent order:
- Which agent sent it, and whether you verified it, for example with a signed request. See how to tell if a visitor is really ChatGPT.
- The order as received: items, quantities, total, shipping address and time.
- Any mandate or intent data the agent sent, kept unchanged.
- Your decision: approved automatically, held for review or declined, and by whom.
- Proof of delivery and your policies as shown at the time of sale.
Prevention is cheaper than winning. Caps, holds for unusual orders and a default decline when nobody reviews in time stop many bad orders before they ship. Our guide to rules for AI agent orders covers the options.
How Sill helps
Sill does not decide disputes; the card issuer does. When an AI agent places an order through Sill, your rules approve it, decline it or hold it for a person to review, and every decision is signed and recorded. Signed audit bundles can be checked by anyone against Sill's published public key, using the in-browser verifier at sill.so/verify. That gives you a dated record of what was approved and why. Run a free readiness scan to see how your store looks to AI agents.
Questions people ask
Can I make AI agent shoppers waive their right to a chargeback?
No, not on Visa. Visa's rules say a merchant must not require a cardholder to waive the right to dispute a transaction, including an agentic transaction, with the issuer.
Is an AI agent purchase a card-not-present transaction?
On Visa, yes when it fits Visa's definition. Visa defines an agentic transaction as an electronic commerce transaction, and its rules forbid agent platforms from making agentic transactions in a card-present environment.
Does ChatGPT handle disputes for orders on my site?
Don't assume so. OpenAI's merchant guide says your business handles the order, fulfillment, customer support and fraud decisions. Stripe's Agentic Commerce Suite also leaves refunds and disputes with the seller.
How long can a shopper dispute an agent purchase?
Stripe says card networks typically allow disputes within 120 days of the original payment, with more time in some cases. Nothing we found sets a different window for agent purchases.
Sources
- Visa Core Rules and Visa Product and Service Rules (24 October 2026 edition) · checked 17 Nov 2026
- Visa Developer: Visa Intelligent Commerce concepts · checked 17 Nov 2026
- Visa: Visa Intelligent Commerce announcement (April 2025) · checked 17 Nov 2026
- FIDO Alliance: FIDO Alliance to develop standards for trusted AI agent interactions · checked 17 Nov 2026
- American Express: Agentic Commerce Experiences · checked 17 Nov 2026
- Stripe Docs: How disputes work · checked 17 Nov 2026
- Stripe Docs: How Agentic Commerce Suite works · checked 17 Nov 2026
- Stripe Docs: Shared payment tokens (sellers) · checked 17 Nov 2026
- OpenAI for Developers: Accept payments · checked 17 Nov 2026
- AP2: Agent Payments Protocol · checked 17 Nov 2026
- AP2: Security and privacy considerations · checked 17 Nov 2026